(already subscribe? log in).

Swim committee to study mixed-gender issue further

THIS STORY APPEARED IN
Boston Articles
January 06, 2012|By Bob Holmes

It was a simple question about an emotional issue at yesterday’s meeting in Franklin of the MIAA Swim Committee: Norwood’s Will Higgins or Wellesley’s Cynthia Kangos?

Kangos set the record in the 50-yard freestyle at the 1985 Girls’ South swimming sectional. The record stood for 26 years until a boy, Higgins, broke it this past November. Higgins’s performance brought to a head a debate that dogged the swim community all fall: What to do about boys who swim on girls’ teams. And what about the records they set?

The Swim Committee embraced half of the debate by forming a subcommittee to study the mixed-gender issue. Said committee chairman Ray Grant of Seekonk, “It’s certainly not a new issue for this committee.’’

Grant said a similar subcommittee was formed three years ago and its recommendation was simply to monitor the issue. With the subject again on the front burner, a subcommittee of Grant, tournament directors Pete Foley and Richard Lennon, plus Belmont’s Jim Davis, Monson’s Patrice Dardenne, Northampton’s James Hirtle, Wahconah’s James Conro, and MIAA assistant director Ned Doyle will decide whether more than monitoring is needed after a fall in which Higgins broke a sectional record and Walpole won the 200 freestyle relay with two boys at the same meet.

No boys won a state title, but Methuen’s Scott DelRossi was second in the 50 freestyle at the Division 1 state championship; Higgins was academically ineligible for the state meet.

The subcommittee will report back to the full committee April 12.

But Grant distanced the committee from answering the question of who holds the South Sectional record, echoing a familiar MIAA refrain: The organization in charge of high school sports since 1978 doesn’t keep individual records in any sport. Therefore, Higgins broke the meet record as recorded by the tournament directors; he didn’t set an MIAA record.

So if the MIAA won’t replace Kangos’s name with Higgins’s, or decide to leave her as the meet record-holder, whose job is it?

“That’s a real good question,’’ said Foley, the retired Weston swim coach and director of the North and South swim meets. “Technically, the meet directors have been the ones who’ve kept the sectional and state meet records. I think what we will have to do is get together with the coaches association and ask them what they want to do. I’ll take the guidance from them.’’

That’s fine with Mike Foley, Pete’s son and the current president of the Massachusetts Swim Coaches Association. Foley coaches the Framingham girls in the fall, the Wayland boys and girls in the winter. Father and son, along with other swim coaches, will discuss the case of Higgins vs. Kangos after the winter season.

Advertisement
Advertisement
|
|
|
|