Lackey conundrum lacks a clear solution

Sunday Baseball Notes

October 16, 2011|By Nick Cafardo, Globe Staff

What do you do with John Lackey?

Hope he performs better?

Hope his troublesome elbow, which is being examined again this week, doesn’t blow out?

Hope you can get the Angels to take him back and get Vernon Wells in return to stick in right field?

It’s not Theo Epstein’s problem. But it is one for new Red Sox general manager Ben Cherington, and it is a pretty big one.

The ideal thing would be to deal him, eat some of the money, and try to obtain Wells, Chicago’s Alex Rios, or another pitcher with similar issues.

Epstein will leave behind the headache that is Lackey but get a bigger one in Carlos Zambrano. And the 30-year-old righthander is a handful, given his explosive personality.

When Zambrano last pitched for the Cubs - Aug. 12, 2011 - he allowed five home runs to the Braves. He eventually was ejected by home plate umpire Tim Timmons for throwing two pitches high and hard to Chipper Jones.

Zambrano took a nutty, cleaning out his locker in the visiting clubhouse in Atlanta and informing the team that he was retiring. The next day, Cubs general manager Jim Hendry placed Zambrano on the 30-day disqualified list, which in effect suspended his pay.

And there’s another issue: He makes a lot of money.

Zambrano is scheduled to earn $18 million in 2012 and has a vesting option for $19.25 million in 2013 if he finishes in the top four in the Cy Young voting and remains healthy.

“The difference between Lackey and Zambrano,’’ said a National League scout, “is that Zambrano can still really pitch. You can’t say the same about Lackey.’’

And that’s where the difficulty lies in attempting to deal him. Talent evaluators and GMs doubt whether Lackey is even a No. 4 or No. 5 starter, whereas Zambrano, if he gets his anger problems under control, could still be a top-of-the-rotation guy.

What’s odd about Zambrano’s situation is that people around the Cubs will tell you he’s one of the most charitable people they’ve ever come across. He gives a lot of money and time to great causes and does it very quietly.

There are all sorts of “garbage-for-garbage’’ deals that could be made with players who have big contracts. The Mariners have Chone Figgins, the Giants Barry Zito, the Nationals Jayson Werth, the Red Sox Lackey and Carl Crawford, the White Sox Adam Dunn and Rios, the Angels Wells, the Braves Derek Lowe, the Yankees A.J. Burnett, the Cubs Alfonso Soriano, and the Mets Jason Bay.

We understand that contracts have to be matched up and in some cases subsidized, but why aren’t GMs willing to be creative and take that change-of-scenery chance?

“I think GMs try to do them,’’ said Yankees GM Brian Cashman. “But you make a deal to get yourself better, and when you analyze it in the end, are you better for having made a deal like that?

Advertisement
Advertisement
|
|
|
|