JACKSON, Miss. — A debate is unfolding over an unusual offer from Mississippi’s governor: He will free two sisters imprisoned for an armed robbery that netted $11, but one woman’s release requires her to donate her kidney to the other.
The condition is alarming some observers who have raised legal and ethical questions. Among them: If the sisters aren’t a good tissue match, does that mean the healthy one goes back to jail?
Governor Haley Barbour’s decision to suspend the life sentences of Jamie and Gladys Scott was praised by civil rights organizations and the women’s lawyer, who have long said the sentences were too harsh.