The Lovely Bones

Broken ‘Bones’: Jackson gets the small, fragile story all wrong

January 15, 2010|Ty Burr, Globe Staff
(Page 3 of 3)

Suspense isn’t what Sebold was writing about, though, and no amount of desperate cinematic retrofitting will make it so. Neither was closure or revenge, which drove some readers batty. Instead, the story’s about forgiveness, reconciliation, moving on - qualities that don’t lend themselves to the epic commercial cinema Jackson represents. The director’s so far out of his element here that he makes one blunder after another, turning Susie’s little limbo pal Holly (Nikki SooHoo) into a childlike ninny, even botching the ghostly climactic resurrection that remains the book’s biggest stretch. (Jackson shows us the wrong character’s face and thus commits his own unseemly act of movie pedophilia.)

“The Lovely Bones’’ isn’t one of those fiascos that’s so bad it’s good. You don’t stand around the smoldering wreckage warming your hands, the way you did with “Glitter’’ or “Battlefield Earth.’’ You just walk away, appalled if you know the novel, confused and vaguely disturbed if you don’t. Jackson once made a fine, unsettling fantasy-drama about teenage girls, “Heavenly Creatures,’’ but that was 16 years ago. These days he can only think big, and so he takes this small, fragile story, and he breaks it.

Ty Burr can be reached at tburr@globe.com. For more on movies, go to www.boston.com/movienation.

Advertisement
Advertisement
|
|
|
|