"Initially, they had me going in to close," said Manny Delcarmen, a logical candidate to stand in for Papelbon, given that he'd made a dozen consecutive appearances without allowing a run and had retired the last 14 batters he'd faced.
Instead, Delcarmen entered in the eighth ("a short inning and I probably would have gone out for the ninth") and that dominance didn't last another batter. Ty Wigginton, the former Tampa Bay Ray, led off the bottom of the eighth with a tying, opposite-field home run, and Lance Berkman, who had been tied up in knots by Jon Lester in whiffing his first three at-bats, sliced an opposite-field, two-run double to climax an improbable comeback.
"I just looked at the video," Delcarmen said. "The pitch to Wigginton was away, and he just got his bat out there. When he hit it, I thought there was no way it had the height to go out. A 3-and-2 pitch, I didn't want to walk him with anything offspeed."
Darin Erstad followed by lining a pinch single ("A hanging curveball," said Delcarmen), and Brad Ausmus, the Dartmouth grad, showed that at 39 he can still drop down a bunt, sacrificing Erstad to second after being sent to pinch hit by manager Cecil Cooper.
Delcarmen struck out Michael Bourn, but walked Hunter Pence before Berkman delivered.
"We made some mistakes out over the plate and we about paid for every one of them," said Sox manager Terry Francona.
The Sox don't expect to lose on a night they score 10 runs, Dustin Pedroia and Mike Lowell each have four-hit nights, Manny Ramírez and Kevin Youkilis each stroke two-run doubles, and Jacoby Ellsbury hits a misjudged RBI triple.
But lose they did, Lowell's solo home run in the ninth off Astros closer Jose Valverde not enough to salvage victory in a game in which the Sox failed to hold leads of 4-0 and 9-6. The last time the Sox lost a game in which they scored 10 runs came almost two years ago, during the Yankees' five-game sweep in August 2006, at Fenway Park.
A three-run home run by former Sox infielder Mark Loretta, on Lester's first pitch after taking Miguel Tejada's comebacker off his left ankle, catapulted the Astros into the lead during a five-run third as they erased the 4-0 advantage the Sox had forged in the top of the inning.