Overdone Maná lacks spice, but Kinky cooks

October 06, 2006

Two of Mexico's premier rock bands take decidedly different paths on their new albums. While Maná delivers an arena-ready set of songs, Kinky takes its electronic indie rock to the party people.

Maná AMAR ES COMBATIR

Warner Música Latina

If we were to speak in culinary terms, the current state of Latin rock resembles a lavish buffet where a wide array of idiosyncratic dishes (Café Tacuba, Babasónicos, Los Amigos Invisibles, Nortec Collective) overwhelm your palate with their bold combinations of sophisticated spices and contrasting flavors. The music of hugely successful Mexican supergroup Maná, on the other hand, evokes the texture of an overcooked burger. To the band's credit, its four members have, throughout years of playing sold-out stadiums, achieved a certain level of instrumental proficiency. And they do look up to the right role models. In the past, they covered Rubén Blades , and on this outing they enlist the bewitching voice of Dominican songwriter Juan Luis Guerra on ``Bendita Tu Luz"-- a lilting ballad with the subtlest hint of Afro-Caribbean fervor. Maná's Holy Grail would appear to be the perfect rock anthem, but the album's antiseptic production work gets in the way of any seriously haunting moods. I suppose this kind of slickly manufactured pop-rock could work a perverse sort of magic if you happened to be drunk beyond your senses at a trashy beach resort. The question is: Would you really want to be there to begin with?

ERNESTO LECHNER

Kinky REINA

Kin-Kon/Nettwerk

Advertisement
Advertisement
|
|
|
|