Vardalos wrote the movie, and it has the same harmless, middle-of-the-road charm that she showed in her script for "My Big Fat Greek Wedding," where ethnicity was made safely generic. (Baklava seemed about as exotic as toast.) "Connie and Carla" is wittier and a little more subversive: Can Vardalos bring drag queens and gay humor to Peoria? The movie is more rambunctious, too. The first 40 minutes are overcaffeinated, manic, and disarmingly sloppy. Some scenes barely hang together, but the arbitrary, almost surreal assembly somehow informs the fun. You root for the nonsense. On the drive to Los Angeles, the mobster's bag of cocaine gets ripped open and clouds the car, and the girls get a contact high that leaves Carla powdered and muttering uncontrollably. In the next scene the car is clean and the girls are sober. It may as well have been a dream.
In LA they wind up at a gay bar where, out of nowhere, a drag show erupts. (Directed by Michael Lembeck, the movie exploits the line between the spontaneous and the last-minute.) The club is looking for a new headlining act, and Connie and Carla's audition bewilders the competition, breaking the lip-synch law of drag shows. "Is she singing," asks one shocked queen about Connie. Yeah, and she's not bad.
Connie and Carla's revue becomes a smash, filled with ridiculous numbers and mini-homilies for the women of LA to love their natural bodies. Carla swears their notoriety will get them caught. But they shouldn't worry. A Russian goon (Boris McGiver) is instead looking for them in every dinner theater in America. Anyway, he really loves "Mame." The man's a pussycat.