Days 13, 14, and 15: After more snorkeling and a hike to the island's summit, we caught a ferry back to Cairns. Hansi's parents returned to the Mercure, and Hansi and I trolled for a decent place to stay, choosing Caravella Backpackers, which runs two local hostels. Craving privacy, we booked a double -- a newly renovated, air-conditioned, white-tiled room with private bath -- for three nights. The room was an ideal home base for a stay that included a daylong trip to the rain forest region of Cape Tribulation with David Sperling, a naturalist and former butterfly breeder who owns Wet Tropics Safaris, and a reef boat trip with Passions of Paradise, a tour company staffed by a tanned, tattooed crew with names like Dirk and Brooksie. Our trip to the reef, an indescribably mesmerizing underwater world of brilliantly colored fish and coral, was our most extraordinary day in Australia. Back at Caravella's, we slept well each night, disturbed only by one false fire alarm that forced a middle-of-the-night evacuation. Cost: $123 ($41 per night).